Arkansas · federal district court · 2025

Nguyen v. Savage Enterprises

District Court, E.D. Arkansas, 26 February 2025. What the court wrote about citations that did not exist, in its own words, from the document on file.

Case record · E.D. Ark.

  1. Court. District Court, E.D. ArkansasCOURT
  2. Level. federal district courtLEVEL
  3. Date. 26 February 2025DATED
  4. Docket. No. 4:24-cv-00815DOCKET
  5. Judge. Brian Stacy MillerJUDGE
  6. Documents. one document, 8 passages quoted belowON FILE
  7. Source. CourtListenerSOURCE

Retrieved · the text below was read from the source documents on that day.

What the court wrote

The passages in which the court addresses the fabricated authority, verbatim, by document. A bracketed ellipsis marks where a passage was cut for length; nothing else is changed.

Docket entry 56, 26 February 2025 · source · PDF · 6 pages

Docket text. RESPONSE re 55 Order,,, Terminate Motions,,, Add and Terminate Parties,,, Add and Terminate Attorneys,, by Diane Nguyen (Sutter, Luther) (Entered: 02/26/2025)

2. In Response, Savage and Wheeler each filed a Motion to Dismiss , which contained arguments that the undersigned counsel and his team has addressed in other states on multiple occasions without resort to fictitious cites. 3.

The young lawyer, other experienced lawyers, and the undersigned worked hand in hand in drafting Complaints and briefs addressing the exact same issues in multiple states, and the young lawyer’s work was more than satisfactory. But the above still does not excuse the filing of filing of a brief containing fictitious cites. 4.

Undersigned checked the brief for content, but did not apparently check the cites. Of note, on review of this matter, Lexis identified some of the fictitious cites but not all of them. Moving forward, the undersigned counsel will manuallycheck the cites for every Brief he files.

Moving forward, the undersigned counsel will manuallycheck the cites for every Brief he files. But the above still does not excuse the filing of a brief containing fictitious cites. 5.

Had a Rule 11 Motion been served, or had defense counsel disclosed the issue, then the Briefing would have been corrected immediately in accordance with the safe harbor. But the above still does not excuse the filing of a brief containing fictitious cites. 6.

After the undersigned read the Reply, he was in the process of researching an appropriate response within the Rule 11 21 day safe harbor, when this Court entered its show cause order. But the above still does not excuse the filing of a brief containing fictitious cites.. III.

Offending passages identified by the Court 1. Although the legal citations at issue here cited to a nonexistent case, each legal proposition was valid, as the Court recognized in its Order denying the Motion to Dismiss. Shockingly, the Brief also contains additional inaccurate citations that were not identified by the Court.

Shockingly, the Brief also contains additional inaccurate citations that were not identified by the Court. But that does not excuse the undersigned filing of a brief containing fictitious cites. IV.

What the text mentions

Pattern matches on the documents' text. Each line is a fact that the text contains the words, not a finding about the case.

Where this fits

This page is a record, not legal advice. It quotes the documents on file and lists what their text mentions. Read the decision at the source before relying on it, and check whether a later order changed it.

More from District Court, E.D. Arkansas, from Arkansas, or from 2025. The whole record is at court decisions on AI-hallucinated citations.

Every case in this record shares one cause: a citation reached a court without anyone opening it. What a citation gate is explains the mechanism that makes that impossible by construction; how to check an AI citation in five minutes is the manual version; the sanctions record is the essay this table grew out of.

Show me on one of my files →

This case is about a cite nobody opened. See a cite checked against the record before it renders, on your own file.

Show me on my files